Geologic Carbon Storage at Outcrop: Lessons for Subsurface Characterization, Modeling, Risk and Monitoring, Utah, USA
This field course will use outcrops from the Cretaceous and Jurassic of Utah to analyze some of the major challenges facing the storage of CO2 in subsurface formations.
Description
Using outcrops from the Cretaceous and Jurassic of Utah, this course will analyze some of the major subsurface challenges facing the storage of CO2 in subsurface formations, with particular reference to the planned Oligo-Miocene carbon stores on the Gulf Coast. It is intended to give participants the opportunity to consider the key factors of injectivity, capacity and confinement, and the range of storage play concepts available to match project needs with practically accessible storage sites. The course will explore the impact of multi-scale reservoir heterogeneity on migration and trapping of CO2, the propagation and dissipation of pressure, and the risks of unintended lateral or vertical migration of CO2 and/or displaced brine. We will also look specifically at boundary conditions and potential leakage paths, including faults and wells, using a variety of outcrops as a natural laboratory to facilitate the learning points.
Tutor(s)
Alex Bump: Research Scientist Associate at Bureau of Economic Geology
Michael Sweet: Co-Director and Research Scientist, The University of Texas at Austin
Duration and Logistics
A 5-day field course comprising a mix of field activities with classroom lecture sessions and discussions. Transport will be by minivan or bus.
Level and Audience
Intermediate. This course is intended for geoscience and engineering professionals working in, or soon to transfer to, CCS projects.
Objectives
You will learn to:
- Describe the subsurface requirements for a successful storage project, including similarities and differences with oil and gas exploration.
- Illustrate the CCS reservoir details of proposed Gulf Coast carbon stores and the state-of-play of these projects.
- Characterize the main depositional features that influence reservoir properties and CCS reservoir development, as well as likely performance, with special reference to clastic coastal/shallow marine depositional systems.
- Gauge fluid transport parameters, including the impact of geological heterogeneity and permeability on CO2 injection and plume migration.
- Evaluate sustainable injection rates for different carbon stores, including pressure propagation and interference, and factors such as loss of injectivity and pressure build-up.
- Manage containment risks with respect to both structural and depositional heterogeneities.
- Validate models for plume migration and integrate the key uncertainties.
Exertion Level
This class requires a MODERATE exertion level. There will be some short hikes to outcrops with some of these over uneven and rocky ground. The climate in southern Utah during the spring and fall is variable, with temperatures from 50°F (10°C) to 100°F (38°C). The elevation is between 4,000 and 5,000 feet (1200 and 1500 meters).
Course Content
The Cretaceous Book Cliffs offer the opportunity to study a variety of clastic coastal/shallow marine deposits, including those interpreted as fluvial, wave- and fluvial-influenced deltaic and shelfal. The course will focus on the proposed carbon stores in the Oligo-Miocene of the Gulf Coast (e.g. Greta Sandstone, Frio Formation) but use outcrops with analogous deposits from the Book Cliffs to consider key carbon storage factors including:
- Injectivity into heterogeneous reservoirs
- Pressure communication
- Pressure barriers
- Sustainable injection rates
- Formation capacity estimation
- Porosity and permeability factors
- Compartmentalization risk
- Seal lithologies and containment risk
- Faults and fractures
The course will be framed around the six major subsurface challenges facing the long-term geologic storage of CO2:
- Legacy wells
- Faults and leakage
- Pressure propagation and interference
- Unintended migration
- Induced seismicity
- Loss of injectivity and pressure build-up
Draft Itinerary
Day 0 Arrival
- Arrive in Salt Lake City, Utah
- Early evening course introduction and safety brief
Overnight in Salt Lake City, Utah
Day 1 Subsurface characterization for CCS
AM Lecture:
- CCUS Play Types (depleted fields vs flat-lying aquifers)
- CCUS examples (North Sea, reusing existing fields, North America – injection into saline reservoirs
- Sand tank models of CO2 flow
- Regional geology of the Blook Cliffs and Paradox Basin
PM Fieldwork: Helper area
We will use outcrops of the Panther Tongue and Spring Canyon Members of the Blackhawk Formation near Helper and in Spring Canyon, Utah to gain insights into reservoir and seal continuity in deltaic and shallow marine, wave-dominated, shoreline deposits. We will also consider the impact of changes in grain size and permeability on CO2 trapping and lateral migration. Core photographs and wireline logs from a series of research cores, cut by Exxon Research and recently made public, will be used to help put what we see in outcrop into a subsurface context.
Overnight in Price, Utah
Day 2 Gulf Coast Carbon Stores
AM Lecture:
- Sandbody connectivity ‘rules’
- CO2 flow pressure, buoyancy, and permeability effects
- CO2 Trapping – residual buoyancy, unsaturated sands and local capillary traps
- Two-phase vs single-phase flow in CO2 reservoirs
- Seals and composite confinement
- Pressure dissipation
- <span">Induced seismicity
AM/PM Fieldwork: Price area
Gentile Wash section of the Blackhawk Formation goes through multiple parasequences in a wave-dominated shoreline deposit culminating in terrestrial fluvial and overbank deposits. The objectives here will be to better understand vertical stacking of these deposits and how their grain size and finer scale sedimentary structure may control the lateral and vertical migration of CO2.
Overnight in Green River, Utah
Day 3 Risk and monitoring
AM Lecture:
- Deltas – facies, geometry and sandbody connectivity
- Effective Kv/Kh
- What is a barrier for CO2?
- Fault transmissibility – is a fault a pathway or barrier to CO2 flow?
- Deformation bands
- Vertical pathways to flow (faults and well bores)
- Well and completion design
PM Fieldwork: Emery and I-70 area
The Ferron Sandstone is a classic and extremely well-exposed, deltaic deposit. Multiple road cuts along I-70 allow for incredible 3-D exposures of pro-delta, delta front clinoforms, distributary channels and other deltaic facies. The fluvial and coastal plain deposits that overlie these deltaic parasequences are also well exposed. The Ferron system is similar in scale to the deltaic deposits of the Wilcox, Frio and Miocene that are seen as targets for carbon storage in the northern Gulf of Mexico.
Overnight in Green River, Utah
Day 4 Subsurface summary
AM Fieldwork: Little Grand Wash Fault/Crystal Geyser near Green River, Utah
The Little Grand Wash Fault is a well-exposed, large-scale normal fault that was activated by movement of the underlying Paradox Salt. It provides an opportunity to discuss the impact of faults as both barriers and pathways to fluid flow. Crystal Geyser, which is actually an abandoned well bore, is a cold geyser driven by migration of CO2 along faults from the underlying Paradox Formation.
PM Fieldwork: Paleo-oil reservoirs of the Navajo Sandstone Canyonlands National Park
The objective of these stops is to look at an exhumed oil reservoir to better understand controls on trap and seal.
Overnight in Green River, Utah
Day 5 Classroom summary
AM Lecture:
- Morning summary and return to Grand Junction for flights home.